|
37 post(s)
|
It has recently been brought to my attention that there are wet and dry carbs. Oatmeal and brown rice are examples of wet carbs because you have to add water to make them. Sweet potatoes/Yams are considered dry carbs. I heard that if you only consume wet carbs or the majority of your diet comes from wet carbs you will look softer then if you ate only dry carbs. Yams are dry carbs and when consumed suck more water from your sub q more then oatmeal or brown rice would leaving you with a harder, leaner and dryer look. This makes sense to me because days before competitions I have been told to only eat yams or rice cakes during my carb up given that those two carbs are dry carbs and there will be less water in my sub q leaving me with a harder and dryer look….This is a new topic for me and I would like to know if I am totally wrong or if what I am saying holds water.
|
|
|
|
882 post(s)
|
ha no pun intended "holds water"
|
|
|
|
1,210 post(s)
|
menna- i don't think that the philosophy behind that is true. yams have water in them, why do you think they shrink when you micro them, the water evaporates, but not all of it. some food allergies can make you hold sub q water. I ate sweet potatoes and brown rice throughout my prep and peek week with no issues with sub q water retention. joe will tell you most likely that there is no real difference between wet and dry carbs. i mean look at oats..i eat mine raw, so does that make it a dry and wet carb, depending on how you cook it??? kind of silly i think
|
|
|
|
37 post(s)
|
I had my doubts about the topic too, although I do feel a little softer after I eat brown rice and I don’t feel as soft after I eat a yam. What you are saying makes sense yams do shrink and if you had dry oats that would make them a dry carb. I just wanted to clear up this rumor
|
|
|
|
897 post(s)
|
Menna this is off MD isn't it? - I was reading that thread - this is going to provide no value but the poster can really be a jack ass..........that.is.all 
|
|
|
|
37 post(s)
|
Haha yea and then I took the info and did some online research and some people agreed with the topic and some didn’t so I brought it here to get an educated answer. I think that guy knows a lot about bodybuilding if you look at his other posts they makes sense, but he needs to take an etiquette class and learn how to talk to people.
|
|
|
|
Administator
4,000 post(s)
|
You are dropping everything you eat into an acid bath. Its then digested and it goes through a series of chemical reactions to become usable glycogen, which is then either used immediately or stored. First in the blood, then the liver, then the muscle. In that order. This takes time...and during that time you are consuming water that will go wherever it is needed. So... Wet or dry has no bearing whatsoever.
|
|
|
|
Administator
2,961 post(s)
|
This takes our sport to a whole new level. I think we pretty much earned the right to be called stupid bodybuilders on this one. Menna - about 15 gallons of water your body. Do me a favor. Fill up two barrels with 15 gallons of water each and then put 1 cup of oats on one and 1 cup of sweet potato or any "wet" carb of your choice. See how dry the barrel with oats looks. Actually, more applicable, see how much of it was absorbed and how far down the water line moved.
|
|
|
|
897 post(s)
|
FANTASTIC - If I soak my oats in 15 gallons do you think they will expand enough that I will think I'm getting more food? And other then Sean who gets a whole cup of oats? - geesh!!
|
|
|
|
1,320 post(s)
|
I am the dumbest person I know, and most likely the dumbest person you guys know, and even I knew that this is stupid idea!!
|
|
|
|
Administator
4,000 post(s)
|
I am off to eat some dry carbs before doing legs today. I want to be DRY when I am hitting my sets. 
|
|
|
|
2,817 post(s)
|
So no syrup on your pancakes?
|
|
|
|
Administator
4,000 post(s)
|
Precisely!
|